A sermon by The Rev. Benjamin J. Newland on Christmas Eve
In that region there were shepherds living in the fields, keeping watch over their flock by night.
Tonight is a shepherd’s night.
We who are church gather in the morning. We come together in the light of day to worship, and praise, and seek. We celebrate by day—God for us is called the Light in the Darkness. We yearn to be people of joy and salvation—people of the Light—and we sing our yearning in the morning.
There are two important exceptions to this rule. One is the Easter Vigil and the other is Christmas Eve. At the Easter Vigil we gather at dusk and look to the past. We remember who God is, and who God has been for us. We recall our roots, our ancestors, our history of faith. Easter is the Feast of the Resurrection, and in the dark of the night before the reality of resurrection is made known we remember that we have been slaves, that we have been liberated, but that we will always have the desert with us. The Easter Vigil is a night for refugees.
But Christmas Eve is a night for shepherds.
Then an angel of the Lord stood before them, and the glory of the Lord shone around them, and they were terrified.
The other exception to our general rule about worshiping in the morning is this night. On Christmas Eve we look to the future. We remember who God is, and who God became for us. We recall the mystery at the core of our faith. Christmas is the Feast of the Incarnation, and in the dark of the night before the reality of incarnation is made known we recall that we were once alone, but that we are alone no longer; we remember that it was once possible to imagine that God did not love us, but that now we know that God is love. Christmas Eve is a night for shepherds.
…the angel said to them, “Do not be afraid; for see– I am bringing you good news of great joy for all the people…
It is no wonder the shepherds were afraid. It was night, and it was dark. Shepherding isn’t really a great job to start with, and to have drawn the night shift put these shepherds at the bottom of a pretty short corporate ladder. More of a corporate step-stool, really. On top of the bad reputation and the low pay, shepherding is both boring and frightening, by turns. Generally it’s just a lot of standing around, until a dangerous animal comes to make a snack out of your charges, or an even more dangerous human comes along to steal some of them.
Also, it was night. The night is dark, and scary. Today we have electricity, and streetlights, and flashlights, and halogen headlights, and LED keychain lights, and brighter-than-daylight stadium lights, and even with all of our lights we still find it possible to be afraid of the dark. The night is not afraid of our lights; it just waits patiently at the edge of our high-beams, until it can come back in again behind us.
So here they are, the shepherds who have the overnight shift, maybe a candle or two between them, and all of a sudden an angel of the lord appears. You can perhaps understand why they were terrified.
“…unto you is born this day in the city of David a Savior, who is the Messiah, the Lord. This will be a sign for you: you will find a child wrapped in bands of cloth and lying in a manger.” And suddenly there was with the angel a multitude of the heavenly host, praising God and saying, “Glory to God in the highest heaven, and on earth peace among those whom he favors!” When the angels had left them and gone into heaven, the shepherds said to one another, “Let us go now to Bethlehem and see this thing that has taken place…
It’s easy for me to imagine that the shepherds were afraid. What’s harder to understand is that, once they’d got over their initial fear, they believed. The one angel tells them that the Messiah is being born as they speak in the town of Bethlehem, and that they can go find him themselves. Then the rest of the angel chorus line also appears, and they sing a song, then they vanish.
And what do the shepherds do? Do they panic and run away? No. Do they pretend it never happened and go back to keeping watch over their flocks by night? No. Do they check themselves into a mental institution due to shared hallucinations? Also, no. They don’t even turn to each other and say, “Huh. That’s somethin’ ya don’t see every day!”. Instead, they simply say to one another, “OK, let’s go check it out.”
Some of you will have heard me say this before, and most of you will hear me say it again: one of my favorite things about history is how the people in it are both just like us, and completely different from us. Even two thousand years ago, people were people. There is more the same between us and those shepherds than there is different. Yet the differences are important, and one of the differences is here: belief.
We worry a lot about belief. What do you believe? Do you believe? Can you believe that? This I believe. Unless you believe on the Lord Jesus Christ you shall not have eternal life. We are very concerned with beliefs, and having them, and having them be the exact right beliefs. When someone who knows nothing about our denomination discovers that I’m a priest, their first question is not, “how do you worship,” but “what does your church believe?”
In this way, twenty-first century people are very different from first century people. Believe is not the same word now that it was then. Easier for them, you might say, when what they had to believe in manifested itself right in front of their eyes. But was it easier? Let’s leave aside for now the fact that we are perfectly capable of not believing things right in front of our eyes even today. If those shepherds believed, they too believed in something they couldn’t verify, at least not for thirty-some years. They found a baby, sure, lying in a manger and wrapped in bands of cloth, but to believe that baby something special was still an act of faith that took years to mature.
So they went with haste and found Mary and Joseph, and the child lying in the manger. When they saw this, they made known what had been told them about this child; and all who heard it were amazed at what the shepherds told them.
Tonight is a shepherd’s night. We remember tonight… A mother and father… a newborn child… a humble place and a humble birth for our God. We remember too that before long there will be wise men of the East, and a angry king, and a flight to Egypt. Then there will be a child presented in the temple, a baptism in the river Jordan, teaching, and healing, and a trial, and suffering, and death. All of these things are to come, but tonight there are just these humble shepherds, who were called and chose to come simply to see.
Tonight is a shepherd’s night, and tonight we are all shepherds, come to see a baby, and to hope he can change the world. AMEN.